JPP Law Blog
Tribunal rejects constructive dismissal claim by ‘bullied’ manager
An employee who claimed he was bullied at work has lost his claim for constructive dismissal.
Paul Bartle worked for Hull City Council social services department as a safeguarding manager. He resigned in 2015 and claimed constructive dismissal.
He told the Employment Tribunal that there was a culture of bullying in the department that had gone unchecked for years. He said he had been repeatedly bullied by the assistant head of service, Claire Brown, who had regularly referred to him as "f...wit" to his face and in front of other staff.
Mr Bartle said the bullying had a serious effect on his health and caused him to take time off with stress. He felt he was not offered the right support by the council and felt unable to return to work, so had no alternative but to resign.
The Employment Tribunal rejected his claim after hearing evidence that the council had dealt with his complaints fairly. It had also tried to support him but he had rejected that help.
Speaking after the judgment, Mr Bartle said: "I had my say and feel satisfied that it got aired. I'm a happy man."
The council issued a statement saying: "We are pleased that the tribunal has found in our favour and that the claim against the authority by Paul Bartle for constructive unfair dismissal has been rejected.
"The tribunal recognised that the council handled Mr Bartle's complaints about mistreatment fairly and did its best to support him but that, unfortunately, he did not accept all the support that was offered.
"We always strive to ensure our employees have the support and dignity at work they are entitled to.
"Any complaints made by employees are taken seriously and the appropriate action taken and support given, as in this case."
Please contact us if you would like more information about the issues raised in this article. To find out more about JPP's employment law services please visit employment law
JPP Law Blog

- Case Studies and Reviews (9)
- Commercial Law (89)
- Dispute Resolution (27)
- Employment Law (118)
- Intellectual Property (2)
- Start-ups (20)
- Videos (8)
- 2021 February (1)
- 2021 January (1)
- 2020 December (1)
- 2020 November (2)
- 2020 October (2)
- 2020 September (2)
- 2020 August (1)
- 2020 July (3)
- 2020 June (1)
- 2020 May (3)
- 2020 April (1)
- 2020 March (2)
- 2020 February (2)
- 2020 January (2)
- 2019 December (2)
- 2019 October (1)
- 2019 September (5)
- 2019 July (3)
- 2019 June (2)
- 2019 May (2)
- 2019 April (3)
- 2019 March (2)
- 2019 February (2)
- 2019 January (2)
- 2018 December (2)
- 2018 October (4)
- 2018 September (12)
- 2018 February (6)
- 2018 January (7)
- 2017 December (2)
- 2018 July (14)
- 2018 June (2)
- 2018 May (13)
- 2018 April (8)
- 2018 March (11)
- 2017 November (6)
- 2017 October (12)
- 2017 September (14)
- 2017 July (7)
- 2017 June (10)
- 2017 May (6)
- 2017 April (4)
- 2017 March (11)
- 2017 February (6)
- 2017 January (1)
- 2016 December (2)
- 2016 September (4)
- 2016 July (1)